Knights Drain - proposed wetland and landscape plan

The Knights Drain project is part of the wider Land Drainage Recovery Programme (LDRP) which seeks to restore the flooding risk in Christchurch to 'pre-earthquake' levels.

Project status: Decision made
Open for feedback: 17 May 2017 to 7 June 2017

Share this

Consultation has now closed

We received 16 submissions with nine respondents in general support, and five respondents supporting the plan but with some concerns.  Two respondents did not generally support the proposal. 

A report was presented to Council and approved at their meeting on Thursday 27 July 2017.

Comments received

Knights Drain feedback [PDF, 244 KB]


Why are we doing this project?

The Knights Drain project is part of the wider Land Drainage Recovery Programme (LDRP) which seeks to restore the flooding risk in Christchurch to ‘pre-earthquake levels’. The Knights Drain catchment has experienced a greater flood risk since the earthquakes due to land damage. We are proposing a scheme that will deliver the necessary storage upstream of the new pump station but also aims to improve water quality prior to discharge into the Avon River.

One way to reduce the flood risk and deliver an efficient system is to provide more storage. The area to the north west of the Pages Road and Anzac Drive intersection is proposed as a site for new flood storage ponds. The ponds will store flood water in heavy rainfall events and slowly release it back to the stormwater network when there is capacity.  This will reduce the flood risk to properties in the adjacent areas and reduce the demands on the existing pump station.  There will still be flooding of streets and properties in extreme flood events after the basin is constructed, but it will be less than what might happen today.  Overall the proposed scheme will increase the resilience of the community by reducing exposure to a range of natural hazards.

The ponds will also provide water quality treatment to the water discharging from the catchment into the Avon River, reducing sediment and contaminants in the water.

Location Map

Location map

What does the preferred option look like?

To provide the required stormwater storage and water quality treatment the area will be dug out by approximately one and a half to two metres to form two ponds. Flow will be diverted into the ponds via a new connection from Knights Drain. The water will travel through the ponds where the sediment and some of the contaminants can settle out and back to Knights Drain upstream of the pump station.

The existing timber lined Knights Drain will be realigned further away from the existing properties and remain connected to provide an overflow path to the pump station in extreme events when the capacity of the ponds has been exceeded. Both ponds will remain wet at all times as the base will be below the water table. The banks of the ponds will be stabilised to prevent any increase in lateral spreading risk to the neighbouring properties. The existing Knights Pond at the north of the site will be retained and enhanced.

The proposed landscape concept for the scheme incorporates native coastal forest and floodplain plants surrounding the ponds to provide shading, support birdlife and reflect and enhance the surrounding environment. The space will be accessible to the public with a footpath and viewing platform where the public can observe the wetland and birdlife from.  Some tree removals will be required to enact the works.  A floating wetland will also be considered at the next design stage to further improve water quality.

The combined ponds and wetland will offer a range of advantages for the long-term management of storm water in the area. The design is based on a six-values approach to managing environments in Christchurch:

*  drainage

*  recreation

*  landscape

*  culture

*  ecology

*  heritage

Planting proposed in and around the new wet-pond area will extend the existing adjacent coastal wetland habitat through the addition of native coastal forest species. The forest and shrubland will be dominated by species like kahikatea and totara with an understorey of locally sourced trees and shrubs. In the future the plantings can be expected to support native bush birds like fantail, grey warbler, bellbird and kereru (NZ wood pigeon) and in the long term even some species that have been absent from the city for many years. As well as providing habitat in their own right, these plantings will also help screen the constructed wetland habitats. These habitats can be expected to support species like Australasian bittern, marsh crake, black and little cormorants and
other native wetland birds.

The proposed scheme means the Council need to acquire 13 residential properties to the north west of the intersection of Pages Road and Anzac Drive. Council already owns a number of properties within the footprint of the works. Property owners that could be affected if the proposed scheme is approved are being contacted directly by Council.

Map

Click to enlarge.

Timeline

Construction timing will be dependent on the acquisition of the residential properties and may be staged.

 

Pump Station - Anzac Drive

New Pump Station - Anzac Drive

What are we seeking feedback on?

We would like to hear your views on the proposed ponds, landscape concept, and any ideas, feedback or concerns you may have.

This feedback will form part of reports to the Community Board and Council for final approval. The Council meeting is planned for July 2017 and all submitters will be advised of meeting details and the proposed recommendation following consultation. This will be followed at a later date by a Community Board meeting for approval of the landscape plan.

Knights Drain - options

How did we establish the preferred option?

The proposed ponds are Council’s preferred option for this catchment. It was selected from a wide range of options as it provides the best improvements in flood storage and water quality upstream of the new pump station. The preferred option also needed to have a reliable outcome and low or infrequent maintenance.

Existing limitations and opportunities within the Knights Drain catchment were identified and mapped. The limitations include ground levels, existing storm water network, other services, depth to groundwater, soil drainage potential, predicted flood depth and extent, and historic and current land use.

The wide range of options developed within the limitations were considered against using a multi-values assessment to establish the preferred option. The assessment included:

  • Christchurch City Council six values (ecology,landscape, recreation, heritage, culture and drainage)
  • Non-flood assessment criteria (resilience including reduction of other hazards e.g. lateral spreading, constructability, ease of implementing the works, disruption to the public, and operations and maintenance).

What were the other options?

Options for providing water quality and flood storage improvements were developed and combined.  Eight combined options were compared using a multi-values assessment.  These options included:

  • The preferred option
  • Storage basins in other locations, such as Bexley Park or the Residential Red Zone
  • Large filter systems at the pump station or rain gardens on streets throughout the catchment to improve water quality

Why is Council’s proposed option preferred?

The proposed option is not the cheapest of the options but the multi-criteria assessment clearly showed that it provided the best value for the community as it best met the objectives of the project and achieved the highest overall ranking.  Other options had similar capital cost as Council’s preferred option but they did not score as well on other criteria.  The preferred option has a high number of benefits, including:

  • It is located at an existing low point in the catchment and adjacent to the Knights Drain, Knights Pond and the new pump station
  • Groundwater is very shallow in this location and the existing soil is poorly drained, so the location is suitable for construction of ponds
  • There are existing residential properties in this location that are likely to be flooded in extreme rainfall events.  The preferred option removes the residents from this risk
  • There are no known contamination sites in this location, but there are known sites in other locations which would make an option in those locations more costly and more difficult to construct
  • Improved landscape, drainage and ecological outcomes, particularly with a wet basin, in comparison to the other options
  • A pond in the proposed location keeps all stormwater assets in one location, adjacent to the existing Knights Drain and Pump Station. This reduces operations and maintenance requirements
  • Provides a resilient long term outcome for remaining low-lying properties that will be impacted negatively by sea level rise

 For further information you can read the Knights Drain Investigation Stormwater Management Options Assessment Report [PDF, 5.1 MB]

Location

Share this

Who to contact

How the decision is made

  • Decision made

Takiuru ki ā mātou ratonga
Log in to our services